Growth is widely regarded as a marker of success, but it can also obscure a company’s strategic focus. The pursuit of expansion often introduces risks that, if unchecked, dilute the very strategy that differentiates a business in the market. This article explores the common causes of such pitfalls and offers actionable insights on how to prevent growth from derailing a company’s strategy.

     

    Understanding the Growth Trap

    Growth often presents opportunities that appear beneficial in the short term but can subtly undermine a company’s core strategic position. Michael Porter’s concept of the “growth trap” explains how organisations, in their drive to expand, may lose the focus that once set them apart.

    Consider the example of Edward Jones, a brokerage firm that established itself by targeting conservative investors in rural areas. Its unique position as the “Walmart of Wall Street” was built on a clear strategy: a network of single-broker branches serving a specific demographic. However, recent moves to attract urban, high-net-worth clients have placed this differentiation at risk. While such changes might seem logical to fuel growth, they can inadvertently compromise the company’s strategic identity.

     

    Why Strategies Become Diluted

    The dilution of strategy during growth occurs for several interrelated reasons, often making it challenging to recognise or address.

    Firstly, the long-term impact of decisions on strategic focus is rarely apparent at the time they are made. It is often only after years have passed that the cumulative effects of these choices become clear. By that point, the damage may be irreparable.

    Secondly, the dilution of strategy is usually the result of multiple incremental decisions rather than one significant change. Each choice, assessed on its individual merits, might seem inconsequential. However, the combined effect of these decisions over time can erode the company’s differentiation.

    Lastly, short-term incentives frequently overshadow long-term goals. Managers, driven by immediate performance targets or career ambitions, may prioritise decisions that generate quick returns. This often leads to investments or initiatives that align poorly with the company’s long-term strategic position.

     

    Identifying Core and Peripheral Elements

    Preventing growth from undermining strategy requires a clear distinction between core and peripheral elements of the strategic position. This approach helps organisations ensure that expansion efforts align with their unique value proposition without jeopardising their identity.

    An analogy from the performing arts offers valuable insights. Opera houses, seeking to attract younger audiences, have often innovated peripheral features—such as the setting and timing of performances—while preserving the core elements of story and music. Similarly, businesses must identify their “core” features and protect them while allowing experimentation with peripheral aspects.

    Core elements are the choices that define a company’s differentiation in the market. These typically relate to three dimensions: the target customers, the goods or services offered, and the way value is delivered. Peripheral elements, on the other hand, are features that can be adapted or evolved to support growth without altering the company’s identity.

     

    Clarifying Core Strategic Features

    Defining core features requires a thoughtful and collaborative effort by leadership teams. This process involves evaluating the strategic choices that underpin the company’s success and identifying those that are essential to its differentiation.

    Effective strategies are often distilled into a few key principles. For example, DPG Media Group, a leading media company in Belgium and the Netherlands, has identified three core elements: providing professional journalism across multiple media channels, dominating small geographic markets, and focusing on market-leading brands. These principles guide the company’s decision-making, ensuring that growth initiatives remain aligned with its strategic priorities.

    Clarity around core elements benefits decision-making at all levels of an organisation. Senior executives can use these principles to rigorously evaluate growth opportunities, while operational managers gain autonomy within defined boundaries. This approach minimises the risk of decisions that inadvertently compromise the company’s strategic position.

     

    The Role of Leadership and Governance

    Strong governance is essential to maintaining strategic clarity during periods of growth. Boards of directors play a critical role in safeguarding a company’s strategy by critically assessing proposed investments. Independent board members, free from day-to-day operational pressures, can challenge management on whether growth initiatives align with the organisation’s core strategic elements.

    This dynamic fosters accountability and ensures that short-term gains are not prioritised at the expense of long-term differentiation. By engaging in these debates, boards contribute to preserving the company’s unique value proposition.

     

    Balancing Adaptation and Stability

    While maintaining a clear strategic focus is vital, businesses must also remain adaptable to changing circumstances. External factors such as technological advancements, evolving customer preferences, and regulatory shifts may require adjustments to strategy.

    However, such changes should be deliberate and aligned with the organisation’s long-term objectives. Adapting to external pressures without compromising core elements ensures that growth supports sustainable value creation.

    At the same time, it is important to recognise that the foundation of a company’s strategy often lies in choices made at its inception. These choices, which form the DNA of the organisation, must be respected and incorporated into future decisions. Failure to consider this legacy can lead to strategic drift and an erosion of the company’s identity.

     

    ***

    Preventing growth from derailing a company’s strategy requires a disciplined approach to decision-making. By identifying and protecting the core elements of their strategic position, businesses can ensure that growth aligns with their unique value proposition.

    Clarity around these core elements empowers leaders to evaluate opportunities critically and equips managers with the autonomy to make decisions within defined boundaries. This approach not only safeguards differentiation but also supports sustainable growth.

    Achieving this balance is essential for long-term success. By maintaining focus and discipline, companies can navigate the complexities of growth while preserving the strategic clarity that defines their identity.

     

    Source: Harvard Business Review (HBR, 2025)

     


    Andriotto Financial Services

     

    At AFS, we are passionate about fostering innovation and empowering ambitious minds to flourish. Our mission is to provide best-in-class financial services for traditional and crypto deals, exploit European grants, and use quantitative methods to improve clients’ performance. We aim to help our customers unlock their full business potential.

    Let’s unlock your enterprise’s full potential together!

    Get in touch at [email protected].