The emergence of platforms like Airbnb and Uber has inspired many imitators. Examples include Plowz, called the “Uber for snowplows,” and Swimply, known as “the Airbnb of swimming pools.” These platforms represent two-sided marketplaces, acting as a connection between buyers and sellers.

    Entrepreneurs often find the marketplace model attractive due to its scalability and profitability. However, while companies like Uber have valuations over $160 billion, many ventures, like GearCommons, an outdoor gear rental service, have failed. GearCommons shut down due to a lack of demand, illustrating the risks involved in this market.

    For those considering creating a two-sided marketplace and aiming to innovate rather than fade away, this article delves into effective strategies, common pitfalls, and examples.

     

    Understanding Two-Sided Marketplaces

    A two-sided marketplace acts as a platform that connects buyers and sellers. This differs from traditional marketplaces like Amazon, where the platform sells directly to customers. Several common types of two-sided marketplaces include:

     

    – Job boards like Indeed, which link job seekers with employers.

    – Freelance platforms such as Upwork, connecting freelancers and businesses.

    – Ride-sharing services like Lyft, which bring together drivers and passengers.

     

    Typically, two-sided marketplaces generate revenue by charging commissions for facilitating transactions between buyers and sellers. For instance, UberEats applies service fees that contribute to the cost of a meal delivery. Alternatively, some marketplaces, particularly job boards, may charge only one party.

     

    Examples of Two-Sided Marketplaces

    The potential for creating a two-sided marketplace exists in virtually any sector where demand is present. The following examples illustrate the versatility of this model.

     

    1. The Quiver

    Founded in 2016 by Rob Bonvetti, The Quiver allows surfers to rent and share surfboards globally. Instead of incurring hefty fees to check surfboards as airline baggage, users can rent boards through this marketplace. To alleviate concerns about potential damage or loss, The Quiver implements a “You break it, you buy it” policy. The platform charges a 10% commission on each rental.

     

    1. Rover

    Launched in 2011 by Aaron Easterly, Rover connects pet owners with dog walkers and sitters. Users can arrange services such as boarding, house sitting, and dog walking. The platform mandates background checks and encourages pet sitters to provide detailed profiles of their experience. A meet-and-greet before bookings is also recommended. Rover takes a service fee of 15-25% from pet care providers and an 11% fee from pet owners.

     

    1. BlaBlaCar

    Founded in France by Frédéric Mazzella in 2004, BlaBlaCar facilitates long-distance carpooling by linking drivers with passengers. With 27 million users across 21 countries, the platform allows riders and drivers to choose their preferred level of conversation. The revenue model includes a booking fee of 16-20% charged to passengers, while drivers incur no fees.

     

    1. TeachersPayTeachers

    Founded by teacher Paul Edelman in 2006, TeachersPayTeachers (TpT) is a marketplace for educators to buy and sell original educational resources. These resources include lesson plans and classroom materials. Success stories, like that of Deanna Jump, a kindergarten teacher from Georgia, showcase the platform’s potential. Jump has earned over a million dollars from her lesson plans. TpT charges a 40% commission on sales for sellers using the free plan and a lower 15% fee for those on the premium plan.

     

    1. UpCounsel

    Founded in 2012 by attorney Matthew Faustman, UpCounsel connects businesses with freelance attorneys for affordable legal services. UpCounsel encountered regulatory challenges that almost caused its downfall. However, its acquisition by a venture capital firm in 2020 enabled it to pivot and expand. The platform now charges attorneys a monthly subscription for access to leads and an 8% commission on legal work.

     

    Advantages of Two-Sided Marketplaces

    The two-sided marketplace model offers compelling benefits for founders, particularly due to its scalability and potential for profitability. Unlike traditional businesses that hold inventory, these marketplaces excel at facilitating transactions between buyers and sellers. This model can lower advertising costs as the network effect fosters growth.

    This model provides substantial advantages for both buyers and sellers. Buyers gain convenient access to a broad selection of products and services, often with enhanced security through third-party booking. Meanwhile, sellers enjoy immediate access to an audience of potential customers, allowing them to focus more on their offerings rather than marketing. Furthermore, the platform streamlines administrative tasks, handling bookings, payments, and communication.

     

    Challenges Faced by Two-Sided Marketplaces

    Despite the advantages, launching a two-sided marketplace presents unique challenges:

     

    • Platform Leakage: If a marketplace charges transaction fees, users may seek to bypass the platform once a relationship is established. This trend can hinder growth and shrink the user base.
    • Quality Control: Maintaining high-quality listings is manageable in the early stages. However, as the platform scales, ensuring the quality of inventory becomes increasingly difficult. Poor-quality listings can erode trust and negatively impact the customer experience.
    • The “Chicken-and-Egg” Dilemma: Attracting buyers is difficult without sellers, and vice versa. This interplay can complicate initial marketplace development. However, successfully navigating this challenge can create a competitive advantage.
    • Winner-Takes-All Dynamics: Established marketplaces that gain user trust and grow their customer base can be hard to displace. Often, markets see fragmentation based on geography, with dominant players in specific regions.

     

    Strategies for Building a Successful Two-Sided Marketplace

    Navigating the challenges of creating a two-sided marketplace requires careful consideration and planning. Here is a set of strategies to enhance the chances of success.

     

    1. Validate the Marketplace Idea

    Before proceeding, it is essential to confirm demand and establish product-market fit. Engaging with potential customers, even if the idea stems from personal experience, can uncover critical insights. Identifying pain points and existing solutions can provide valuable context. Exploring platforms like Facebook Marketplace can also indicate a healthy informal market.

     

    2. Identify Fatal Flaws in the Marketplace Model

    After validating the idea, it is crucial to critically assess the marketplace model. Key questions include the risk of platform leakage and whether physical inventory will be managed directly. The frequency and value of transactions are also significant factors to consider, as low-dollar, low-frequency transactions can hinder revenue generation.

     

    3. Develop a Minimum Viable Product (MVP)

    Creating a marketplace does not require extensive financial investment upfront. Instead, the goal should be to launch an MVP as quickly as possible. Utilising no-code app builders tailored for marketplaces can expedite this process. Platforms like Sharetribe or Tangram offer effective solutions.

     

    4. Attract Sellers First, Then Buyers

    In many cases, it is advantageous to recruit sellers before buyers to overcome the initial chicken-and-egg problem. Initial outreach can occur through personal networks or cold outreach to active sellers on other platforms, offering incentives such as reduced commissions.

    Once a solid base of sellers is established, efforts can shift to attracting buyers. However, scaling should be approached cautiously to maintain balance and avoid mismatched supply and demand.

     

    5. Establish Trust

    Creating a sense of trust is vital for marketplace success, whether users are renting surfboards or seeking legal advice. Ensuring high-quality seller listings and well-completed buyer profiles fosters trust from the outset. As the marketplace grows, implementing features like user verification, insurance, and escrow services can further enhance user confidence.

     

    6. Deliver Value to Retain Users

    To prevent user leakage, a marketplace must provide substantial value. Although some users may seek to connect directly outside the platform, offering unparalleled convenience and experience is key. By addressing challenges like payment processing and fraud prevention, users are more likely to remain engaged.

     

    ***

    Establishing a successful two-sided marketplace requires meticulous planning, market validation, and a commitment to providing exceptional value. The potential for scalability and growth is significant, but several pitfalls can lead to failure. By diligently validating ideas, choosing the right model, starting small with an MVP, and fostering trust, the foundation for a long-lasting marketplace can be built.

     

    Andriotto Financial Services

     

    At AFS, we are passionate about fostering innovation and empowering ambitious minds to flourish. Our mission is to provide best-in-class financial services for traditional and crypto deals, exploit European grants, and use quantitative methods to improve clients’ performance. We aim to help our customers unlock their full business potential.

    Let’s unlock your enterprise’s full potential together!

    Get in touch at [email protected].